Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Protestantism and Mysticism
  • A Brief Lecture
2
The Effects of the Reformation
  • Neither post-Reformation Protestantism or Catholicism was as open to the mystics as the church of the Middle Ages.


  • Heavy Emphasis on correct teaching:
    • Council of Trent
    • The Protestant Confessions
3
Hostility
    • Aside from a handful of Protestant liberals, most Protestant theologians have been opposed to mysticism and the mystical impulse.


    • Martin Luther’s favorite phrase for his non-
    • Catholic enemies was “Swarming Spirits,” and he pictured many of his opponents as mystics who replaced the sure Word of God with the vagaries of their own experience.
4
Different Languages
  • I would argue that much of Protestant mysticism went underground and adopted a language that was self-consciously different from that of Catholic mysticism to describe somewhat similar experiences:
    • Conversion
    • Presence of the Holy Spirit
    • The religion of the heart
5
Fewer Places for Women
  • Protestantism rarely generated the various religious orders, monasteries, confraternities, etc. that provided special places for women in Catholic Europe.
  • Interestingly, although they were not published, some Protestant groups, such as the Puritans that stressed religious experience did have many women diarists and writers of private papers.


6
Thomas Muentzer
  • Modern liberationist theologians have rediscovered Thomas Muentzer.
  • A contemporary of Luther, he served the radical parish of Zwickau (home of the Zwickau prophets) and the parish at Allsted.
  • Rejected infant baptism in favor of a baptism of the spirit.
  • Caught up in the interpretation of Daniel and Revelation
  • Became a leader in the Peasant’s Revolt of 1525 and was executed when the great cause failed.
7
Kaspar
Schwenckfeld
  • 1489 Birth in Ossig, Silesia.
  • 1518 Spiritual Awakening
  • 1523 Rejects Luther’s Understanding of the Supper
  •  Series of Public Debates with Lutheran Pastors, separated by periods of exile
  • 1551 Dies and his body secretly buried, perhaps in Ulm.
  • His followers still have a “church” in Philadelphia


8
Celestrial Flesh of Christ
    • Jesus' flesh, he taught, was increasingly divinised by his divine nature during his earthly sojourn, so that it was transfigured and thereafter resurrected, taken up, and glorified at the right hand of the Father. It is on this glorified flesh that the believer feeds by faith; it is this flesh which by faith believers spiritually partake of, and which, in turn, grows like a grain of mustard in them as they grow daily in the image of Christ.

9
Revelation is Continuing
  • From this it is clear that even the beloved disciples of Christ did not know or understand everything at once, that the Lord did not reveal everything to them in the years He was with them, nor did he bind their consciences to his oral teachings alone, much less present them with Articles of faith; rather, He let their minds open to the Holy Spirit and preserved for Him a free judgment in His disciples. It was then for the Holy Spirit to take from the riches of Christ whatever He wished to teach them; indeed, He is the Spirit of the Lord who honors and glorifies Christ, and leads Christians into all truth.


10
Schwenckfeldians
  • Persecuted until the 18th century
  •  Were protected for a season on the estate of Count Nicholas von Zinzendorf
  • Forced to flee after the death of the Prince in 1733, they went to Pennsylvania where a handful continue the traditions of Schwenckfeld’s mystical views of Christ and the Sacrament.
  • One congregation in Norristown, Pa is part of the United Church of Christ.
11
Sebastian Franck
  • Contemporary of Luther
  • Early forced into exile for his view that Christians did not doctrinal standards but could trust the Holy Spirit to lead them into truth.
12
Hans Denck
1495-1527
  • Graduate of the University  of Ingolstadt expert in Greek and Laton
  • One of the original group that baptized themselves and founded the Swiss Brethren in 1525.
  • Died of the plague in 1527 after two years of wandering in exile.


13
God Ordains Evil
  • "It is better that he had ordained sin than that he had prevented it, which he could not have done without having forced and driven men like a stone or a block. . . . For sin is over against God to be reckoned as nothing; and however great it might be, God can, will, and indeed already has, overcome it for himself to his own eternal praise without harm for any creatures." (Whether God is the Cause of Evil)
14
Denck on Revelation
  •  God “speaks clearly in everyone, in the deaf, dumb, and blind, even in unreasoning beasts, even in leaves and grass, stone and wood, heaven and earth, and all that is in them, that they may hear and do his will. In man alone, who does not want to be nothing and yet is even more than nothing, is there resistance to it."


15
The New Birth
  • It is not enough for God to be in you; you must also be in God."


16
The Principle of Tolerance
  • “But you, if you hear your brothers say something that is strange to you, do not at once contradict, but hear whether it be right, whether you may accept it. If you do not like to hear it, still, do not condemn him, and if it appears to you that he is mistaken, consider whether you may not be more mistaken."


17
Franck As Historian
  • Part of Franck’s significance is that he, along with Matthias Flacius Illyricus (1520-1575) was among the first to give the heretics an important place in the history of the church.


18
The Real Church
  • Franck maintained that the real church was the group of people who had experienced the Spirit and that no institution could stand in the place of this body as God’s beloved child.
19
On Religious Freedom
  • “If I had the choice I should prefer to be among those whom the world condemned as heretics rather than among those who have been esteemed as saints”



20
 Jakob Boehme (1576-1624),
  • Greatest Protestant mystic
  • Very difficult to read.
  • Shoemaker and seller of gloves
  •  He was in constant tension with the Lutheran Church authorities.


21
Sophia
  • Deeply interested in the idea of Sophia which he renewed for his own time.



22

The Exotic
  • Philippus Aureolus Paracelsus
  • Very interested in alchemy, in the quest for new forms of natural knowledge.
  • Many words from the magical and alchemical vocabulary appear in his writings/
23
Visions
  • “No word can express the great joy and triumph I experienced, as of a life out of death, as of a resurrection from the dead! . . . While in this state, as I was walking through a field of flowers, in fifteen minutes, I saw through the mystery of creation, the original of this world and of all creatures. . . . Then for seven days I was in a continual state of ecstasy, surrounded by the light of the Spirit, which immersed me in contemplation and happiness. I learned what God is, and what is his will. . . . I knew not how this happened to me, but my heart admired and praised the Lord for it!"


24
 
25
Boehm’s View of the World
  • God’s Movement from Godsself


26
 
27
The Reconciliation of Opposites
  • Nicholas of Cusa had posed the problem.
  • Boehme’s idea is the fact of Duality implies a deeper unity.
  • God can do this by being the ground that lies beyond the opposition or contradiction.
  • “The Ungrund of the unmanifested Godhead is boldly represented in the English translations of Boehme by the word Abyss, in a sense altogether unexplained by its Biblical use.”



28
Influence on Quakers
  • During the Civil War, his English followers tended to merge with the Quakers
29
George Fox
  • Born in 1624; died in 1691.
  • Came to maturity in the period leading to the English Civil War.
  • Period of intense controversy over religion as new groups, both somewhat orthodox and less than orthodox, became common.
  • One of the primary issues that separated Anglican from Puritan was the question of regeneration and whether conversion was needed.
30
George Fox

  • Classical Seeker of the period, wandering from teacher to teacher for answers.
  • Increasingly found his answers within himself.  God told him, for example, that one did not have to go to Oxford or Cambridge to become a priest.
  • God also told him that physical holy places or churches were not necessary.
31
Fox’s Distress
  • As I cannot declare the misery I was in, it was so great and heavy upon me, so neither can I set forth the mercies of God unto me in all my misery. O the everlasting love of God to my soul, when I was in great distress!



32
Fox’s Vision
  • One day, when I had been walking solitarily abroad, and was come home, I was taken up in the love of God, so that I could not but admire the greatness of His love; and while l was in that condition, it was opened unto me by the eternal light and power, and I therein clearly saw that all was done and to be done in and by Christ, and how He conquers and destroys this tempter the devil, and all his works, and is atop of him; and that all these troubles were good for me, and temptations for the trial of my faith, which Christ had given me.
33
God As Teacher
  • In 1743, he had a deep spiritual crisis which he documented in his Journal of Dreams.
  • God became his teacher:I saw also in vision that fine bread on a plate was presented to me; which was a sign that the Lord Himself will instruct me since I have now come first into the condition that I know nothing, and all preconceived judgments are taken away from me; which is where learning commences; namely, first to be a child and thus be nursed into knowledge, as is the case with me now.


34
Public Ministry
  • Began in 1648 when he began to preach publically and to gather followers.
  • Movement came to be called “Quakers”because they often shook when they preached.
  • Frequently imprisoned.  Over 1,000 in prison in the 1650s.
  • Puritans in Boston hung 4 Quaker women at this time.
35
The Inner Light
  • Everyone receives what they need from God in order to be accepted by God.


  • The Bible is valuable, but it is not as important as the God within who validates the Scriptures or, in some cases, invalidates them.
36
Implications
  • Religious Equality Between Men and Women
  • A different way of raising children.
  • Like the Anabaptists, no oaths; no signs of respect to worldly authority.
  • After the restoration, the Quakers came to accept pacifism on the basis of the shared light of all people


37
Walt Whitman on Fox
  • George Fox stands for something too—a thought—the thought that wakes in silent hours—perhaps the deepest, most eternal thought latent in the human soul. This is the thought of God, merged in the thoughts of moral right and the immortality of identity. Great, great is this thought—aye, greater than all else."


38
Emanuel Swedenborg
    • Born in 1678 in Stockholm
    • His father was a noted bishop
    • Made his money the old-fashioned way: he inherited it from his second wife
    • Deeply interested in science: studied in England
    • Founded the journal Daedalus Hyperboreus that became the foundation of the Swedish Royal Society of  Sciences
    • nebular hypothesis first published by him
    • Interested in spiritualism and is said to have contacted the Queen of Sweden’s brother for her.

39
Arcana Coelestia
  • Eight quarto volumes were published anonymously in London between 1749 and 1756
  • The work is a mystical meditation on the books of Genesis and Exodus.
  • The theory of “correspondences” shows that what “is” on earth corresponds to what “is” in the world beyond.




40
Heaven and Hell
  • Believed that the earth and heaven are separated by a world of spirits that stands between the two.
  • Argued that it was scientifically and religiously necessarily that human life exist throughout the universe.
41
Scripture Compared to Humanity
  • Without such a Life, the Word as to the letter is dead. The case in this respect is the same as it is with man, who--as is known in the Christian world--is both internal and external. When separated from the internal man, the external man is the body, and is therefore dead; for it is the internal man that is alive and that causes the external man to be so, the internal man being the soul. So is it with the Word, which, in respect to the letter alone, is like the body without the soul.


42
Governed by Spirits
  • Man is altogether ignorant that he is governed of the Lord through angels and spirits, and that with every one there are at least two spirits, and two angels. By spirits man has communication with the world of spirits, and by angels with heaven. Without communication by means of spirits with the world of spirits, and by means of angels with heaven, and thus through heaven with the Lord, man could not live at all; his life entirely depends on this conjunction, so that if the spirits and angels were to withdraw, he would instantly perish.


43
People Influenced
  • Swedenborg deeply influential on Emerson, Blake, Henry and William James, and others.
  • One of the most important speculative systems proposed in the Protestant church.


44
Other Protestant Mystics
  • William Law
  • Henry More
  • Jonathan Edwards
  • Ephrata Cloister